There’s a term that was coined in the 1990s: “internet addiction.” But it’s no longer sufficient; it’s become outdated. For that reason, the commission convened by the prestigious journal The Lancet Psychiatry has decided to use another one: “problematic usage of the internet” (PUI).
In a paper published on Thursday, the commission estimates that PUI affects at least 10% of the global population. This situation encompasses everything from gambling and online gaming disorders to addictive pornography consumption, as well as “emerging” behaviors like “cyberchondria” — the same old hypochondria, only now amplified by the infinite and terrifying possibilities of internet searches. Consequently, the authors of the article urge governments and institutions to prioritize public health over industry interests.
More than 30 researchers from universities across five continents took part in the study, coordinated by 26 commissioners, including psychiatrists, psychologists, economists and neurologists. The effort aims to tackle complex and pressing mental health challenges and to issue recommendations for public policy.
The scale of the issue becomes clear from the commission’s own figures: more than 6 billion people use the internet worldwide, roughly three out of every four people on Earth. There are more than 5.79 billion social media user accounts, representing nearly 70% of the global population. And young people aged 16 to 24 spend, on average, more than three hours a day on social media at least four times a week.
Problematic design
Although the report acknowledges that genetic, social and psychological factors influence how individuals engage with activities such as online gambling, the researchers warn that problematic usage of the internet cannot be explained solely by individual vulnerabilities; it is also shaped or amplified by the design characteristics of digital services. In other words, apps, algorithms and websites exploit mechanisms such as push notifications, the constant alerts that pop up on a phone screen, social media “likes,” streaks and achievement badges as part of a strategy to develop habitual and automated (that is, mindless) use.
According to the commission, there is enough evidence that social media platforms, e-commerce services, online shopping sites and gaming platforms use advances in the scientific understanding of the brain’s reward mechanisms. They provide what they know the brain craves. But beyond that, The Lancet article argues, these features are often implemented without users’ explicit awareness, without warnings or measures to manage the consequences, at the expense of users’ own wellbeing. And all of this is taking place without clear regulatory limits.
It doesn’t affect everyone the same way
Problematic usage of the internet (PUI) isn’t a universal force. It can affect a middle-class woman in her twenties living in Pakistan differently than the brand-new James Bond, the forty-something British actor Robert Pattinson. According to the study, PUI seems to be more prevalent in low- and middle-income countries than in high-income countries. And, while it can harm people throughout their lives, young people appear to be especially vulnerable.
The report also identified some gender-based trends. Men tend to show higher rates of problems related to gambling, video games and pornography consumption, whereas women are more likely to experience problematic use of social media, compulsive online shopping and cyberchondria.
That is a reality Susana Jiménez, head of Clinical Psychology at Bellvitge Hospital in Catalonia, knows firsthand. The team she leads treats around 350 new cases a year, most of them linked to gambling disorders, which account for roughly 87% of the total.
In a call with EL PAÍS, Jiménez, who was not involved in the research published by The Lancet Psychiatry, clarifies that only “the most serious cases” receive clinical attention. Hence, she welcomes the fact that the publication of the experts’ findings draws attention to some of the phenomena that typically get less attention.
The proposals
The Lancet Psychiatry paper proposes drawing on some of the lessons learned from efforts to curb alcohol and tobacco use, such as banning advertising at sporting events and other large-scale public venues. However, the authors argue for an approach that goes well beyond simple restrictions.
For example, the study argues that access bans such as those introduced by countries like Australia, and currently being considered by several European Union members, including Spain, should not become the primary regulatory strategy.
Antonio Rial Boubeta, a psychology professor at the University of Santiago de Compostela, agrees. In his view, measures that impose age restrictions on access to social media platforms such as TikTok and Instagram are “insufficient.” While he describes the commission’s work as “rigorous and necessary,” he argues that the report is precisely at its weakest when it comes to proposed actions. An expert on cyberaddiction, Rial believes the seriousness of the problem calls for far more concrete measures: “We are being far too permissive with the industry.”
Jiménez, the specialist from Bellvitge Hospital, likewise stresses the need for stronger regulation of these industries. It is a theme that also runs through the report published on Thursday, reflecting a growing recognition that the time has passed when major technology companies, particularly social media platforms, could be trusted to regulate themselves.
The authors adopt a more diplomatic tone, calling for regulatory frameworks where adoption does not depend primarily on industry self-regulation. Jiménez goes further, emphasizing that “the responsibility for ensuring healthy use of new technologies cannot fall on families, educators, healthcare professionals, or individuals alone.” Rial Boubeta is the most outspoken of all: “From now on, we need to stop believing in industry self-regulation.”
Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition