Champs-Élysées with Arc de Triomphe View, Paris. Credit: Pexels, Casper Sami
France’s controversial Zones à Faibles Émissions (ZFEs) – the country’s version of Ultra Low Emission Zones (ULEZ) – could soon be drastically scaled back or even scrapped.
What are ZFEs in France and why are they under scrutiny?
Established under French laws in 2019 and 2021, ZFEs were designed to reduce air pollution in major cities by restricting older, more polluting vehicles – like ULEZ. Motorists are required to display a Crit’air sticker, and as of January 2024, diesel cars registered before 2006 are banned from entering cities like Paris and Lyon. Offenders risk fines of up to €135.
According to Le Monde, around three million vehicles are currently affected. The goal is to curb the 48,000 premature deaths annually linked to fine particle pollution in France.
However, opposition to the scheme has intensified, with critics saying it disproportionately impacts low-income drivers and rural residents. Half of those driving into ZFEs live outside the cities and are often ineligible for support schemes, The Telegraph reports.
A multi-party group of MPs – including members of the far-right National Rally, the conservative Republicans, and even some from President Macron’s Renaissance party – is calling for a rollback. A vote in the French National Assembly is expected soon.
Jordan Bardella, leader of National Rally, said, “Accepting ZFE means accepting punitive and anti-social environmental measures.” Laurent Wauquiez of the Republicans went further, branding the policy “economic suicide.” (Cited by Daily Mail.)
French Prime Minister François Bayrou previously acknowledged that “it is the poorest… who are the victims.”
Protests erupted across France on April 6, led by author Alexandre Jardin and the “Les Gueux” movement, labelling the policy as “institutionalised social segregation.”
French government wants to relax, not remove, ZFEs
The French government appears unwilling to fully reverse course. Minister for Ecological Transition Agnès Pannier-Runacher told Le Figaro: “Everyone has the right to move around, but also to breathe… That is what is at stake in this amendment.”
She insists ZFEs are “one of the tools for reducing air pollution, particularly in large conurbations,” and has proposed limiting mandatory ZFEs to only those cities – like Paris and Lyon – where pollution levels exceed WHO thresholds.
A new initiative dubbed the ‘Air Quality Roquelaure¡ will bring together local officials to refine pollution-reduction strategies, according to Novethic.
The costs of scrapping ZFEs
Scrapping ZFEs could have serious financial repercussions. France risks losing €3.3 billion in EU funding for 2025 alone, part of a €40.3 billion package allocated under the National Recovery and Resilience Plan, Contexte reports.
The French Treasury warns that abolishing the zones could be viewed by the EU as defaulting on commitments – possibly triggering a €1 billion repayment request.
The final outcome of ZFEs hinges on a vote in France’s fractured parliament, where turnout and cross-party consensus remain uncertain. While a full cancellation is unlikely, a significant softening of the rules seems imminent.
Let us know your thoughts below: Should pollution control come at the cost of mobility for the poorest? Or are clean air and climate targets too critical to compromise?
View all news from France.