One of the most frequently used arguments by the Donald Trump Administration to justify its campaign against migrants is that they take advantage of public funds, harming Americans. Multiple studies have shown the opposite. The most recent one, published Tuesday by the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank in Washington, D.C., finds that immigrants have a net positive impact on the U.S. economy. “Immigrants have paid more in taxes to every level of government than they have received in government benefits every year since 1900,” states David J. Bier, one of the co-authors.
According to the study, immigrants have reduced federal, state, and local government deficits every year for the last 124 years by a cumulative $14.6 trillion. As a share of gross domestic product (GDP), the immigrant surplus was more than twice as fiscally beneficial in 2023 as in 1913, before the modern welfare state and individual federal income tax, reads the report.
“In real inflation-adjusted terms, the immigrant surplus in 2023 was more than 53 times larger than in 1913: $585 billion versus $11 billion. Of the $14.6 trillion in immigrant fiscal surplus, 86 percent has accrued since 1965 and the creation of the modern Great Society welfare state,” says the study.
Titled “Immigrants’ Historical Effects on Government Budgets: 1900–2023,” the paper attempts to calculate allocations of government spending to immigrants and natives for each year of the 20th century to show how this fiscal benefit has changed over time, notes Bier. The study concludes that immigration has never been as positive, both fiscally and economically, as it is today.
The analysis highlights that the biggest difference from past eras is that today’s migrants are much more productive —and therefore pay more taxes per capita— than those in 1913, producing a larger net fiscal surplus. “When immigrants come to America and work, they help make the country a wealthier and more prosperous place. Congress should reform outdated laws that restrict immigration based on the false premise that immigrants are economically harmful,” the authors David Bier and Julián Salazar say.
Passing reform of a broken immigration system is one of the issues the new Congress resulting from the November 3 midterm elections will face. When it is sworn in on January 3, Democrats will hold majorities in both chambers. In the days after the midterms, several Democratic lawmakers voiced support for using that majority to pass a pathway to legalize undocumented migrants who have been living and working in the U.S. for years.
Since Trump returned to the White House, many of these workers have lost their legal resident status and have been targeted in arrests and deportations by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The administration blames undocumented migrants for straining public finances, but in reality these workers pay taxes and cannot access any federal benefits.
Since 1776, some 130 million immigrants have arrived in the United States. According to the research, many people believe that while immigration benefited the country in the past, the welfare state has removed —or at least reduced— that benefit because of the cost of government services and payments to immigrants.
However, although public spending has grown over the years, it has not reduced the fiscal benefit migrants provide, because tax revenues have grown as well. In the early 20th century the government established new taxes —including income taxes and Social Security contributions— that have offset the increase in welfare spending over the last century.
In 2023, fewer than 4% of applicants for legal permanent resident cards (the green card) were approved. A better policy would be based on the premise that immigrants bring fiscal and economic benefits to the country, the study says. “Prior to 1921, more than 98% of immigrant applicants were approved to receive permanent residence. That system better reflected American traditions and economic reality. Congress should return to the presumption of openness and reauthorize peaceful immigrants to come to the United States legally,” the authors argue.
They work more and earn less
Migrants earn lower hourly wages, but generate higher total income per capita than natives because, for more than a century, they have been more likely to work. In 2023, immigrants had an employment rate —the share of people employed relative to the population— 14 percentage points higher than that of U.S.-born Americans. The share of the immigrant population in its prime working years is typically higher than that of the U.S.-born population. In almost every year of the 20th century and the early 21st, the average immigrant paid more in taxes than the average U.S.-born person. By contrast, between 1994 and 2023 immigrants used between 18% and 25% fewer benefits.
Bier and Salazar contradict Milton Friedman, who said that “free immigration was a good thing before 1914, and free immigration is a bad thing today.” “Milton Friedman failed to consider that the worse the fiscal situation of the United States, the more beneficial new immigrants become.,” they say in response to the famed economist.
Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition