In December 1952, a contingent of hundreds of artists, writers, doctors, jurists, and teachers traveled to Vienna for the Congress of the Peoples for Peace. In its March 1953 editorial, the magazine Tiempo — which opened with a text by Rafael Alberti on Stalin’s death and one of the speeches delivered by the Russian dictator in life — wrote: “The finest representatives of art and science from every country on Earth proclaimed before Congress their determination to preserve peace intact, knowing that this defense is the best defense of themselves and their creative potential.” Frida Kahlo dedicated a painting to that meeting, one that was due to go up for auction in New York on November 17 at Christie’s and whose sale has so far been prevented after a claim by the Mexican government, which has requested “full information on its provenance” from the auction house. Among the doubts it harbors lies a central question: when did Kahlo’s work, Congress of Peoples for Peace, finally leave Mexico?
A group called Defend the Gelman Collection maintains that the painting is listed in the inventory Diego Rivera compiled when he created the Casa Azul Trust in 1957 and is therefore “part of the legacy he left to the People of Mexico.” That information is also confirmed to EL PAÍS by the painter Pedro Diego Alvarado, Rivera’s grandson, who places the painting “in Frida’s studio and among the belongings of the Casa Azul.” The group alleges that Congress of Peoples for Peace “left the Casa Azul for strange reasons and came into the hands of a New York gallery owner, and after several transfers and an auction it ended up in private hands that are now offering it, through Christie’s, for between $2 million and $3.5 million.” The association, which has already criticized the Mexican government’s management of the Gelman collection, had asked for the auction to be stopped.
For its part, the National Institute of Fine Arts and Literature (INBAL) had explained in an initial statement that “the painting left Mexico more than three decades before the publication of the decree [in 1984] that declared Frida Kahlo’s work an artistic monument.” “In previous cases, INBAL has clarified that the ban on definitive export applies to works that were on national territory at the time the decree was published,” the government said, basing its position on the assertion that the painting left the country in 1952 for Vienna specifically for that Congress. However, Christie’s itself records that the work returned to Mexico in 1953 to be shown at Kahlo’s first exhibition in April of that year. After that there is a gap of decades until the next recorded showing. Under pressure, INBAL asked that the auction be postponed “until the information is clarified.”
“Revolutionary Realism”
Exactly between day and night, a white dove perches on a huge tree. Between the roots, in uppercase letters, reads: “Congreso de los pueblos por la paz.” The work is signed by Frida Kahlo and dated “oct.52.” There is no mystery behind the painter’s intent: to support that movement, which condemned the Korean War and the use of weapons of mass destruction. She recounts it herself in her diary, when that autumn she wrote: “For the first time in my life painting is supporting the line traced by the party. Revolutionary Realism.” In an entry dated November 4 of that same year, she adds: “For 25 years I have been a communist being.”
Scholars who contextualized the work, such as Mexican historian Luis Martín Lozano in his book Frida Kahlo. Complete pictorial work, explain: “In her painting, Kahlo expressed her hope that the seed planted by the Congress would become a robust tree deeply rooted in the earth, from whose branches the succulent fruits of freedom would abundantly sprout for all peoples, while a white dove, the universal symbol of peace, would settle on its highest branches for humanity in the days and nights to come.”
There is another consensus about Congress of Peoples for Peace: Kahlo could never have traveled with the painting to the meeting in Vienna for which it was intended. By then, the artist already needed constant medical assistance and was painting from her bed. The historian and art critic Raquel Tibol recorded that it was Diego Rivera and his daughter, architect Ruth Rivera Marín, who traveled to Europe and carried the painting. The historian wrote this in August 1986 in UNAM’s Revista, under the title Artistas por la paz (Artists for Peace), where she highlighted the “very significant efforts to join forces in order to stop the production of war instruments.”
However, according to Christie’s, the painting returned to Mexico. In April 1953 Kahlo’s first and only solo exhibition was held at the Galería de Arte Contemporáneo, run by her friend, photographer Lola Álvarez Bravo. It was an homage to the painter, whose health was deteriorating. She arrived at the show in an ambulance and appeared on a wheeled bed, dressed in Tehuana attire. “With friendship and affection born from the heart I have the pleasure of inviting you to my humble exhibition,” Kahlo wrote for the date April 13, “at 8.00 p.m. — for you do have a clock, after all .” The auction house (and Sotheby’s) states that one of the works that appeared in that exhibition was Congress of Peoples for Peace.
Then there is a 24-year gap until the painting reappears in the exhibition Tarsila, Frida, Amelia, organized by Fundación La Caixa in Madrid and Barcelona in 1997, according again to information released by Christie’s and Sotheby’s. Christie’s locates a third exhibition, Frida Kahlo and Her Time: The Surrealist Women of Mexico, which toured several museums in Japan between 2003 and 2004.
From there, further silence until June 2020, when Sotheby’s announced the sale of the painting by the Ramis Barquet Gallery in New York, then for about $600,000. It was purchased by a private collector. During Tuesday’s auction at Christie’s, the work was expected to reach $3.5 million.
Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition