The Democrats’ historic victory at the November 3 midterm election promises to usher in a new era in Washington. It also opens the door to ending an electoral anomaly: the fact that the United States is the only presidential democracy in the world where the president is not elected directly by voters, but by an Electoral College.
Here’s how it works: the Constitution assigns each of the 50 states a number of electors equal to its representation in Congress, two senators per state plus a number of members of the House of Representatives based on population, ranging from one to 52. With the exception of Maine and Nebraska, the candidate who wins a state receives all of its electoral votes, whether the margin is a single ballot or two million.
Because Democrats won control of the governorship and both chambers of the state legislatures in Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Arizona and Nevada on November 3, advocates of this far-reaching reform now see a path to securing the support they previously lacked.
Their strategy is to pass the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, a legal framework first proposed in 2007 as an alternative to a constitutional amendment, which would be nearly impossible to achieve in a country as politically polarized as the United States.
The compact has already been approved by 18 states and the District of Columbia, home to Washington. To take effect, it must be adopted by states representing a combined 270 electoral votes, the same number required to win the presidency.
So far, states accounting for 222 electoral votes have joined. If Arizona, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Nevada, the five states that have just turned blue, were to sign on, their combined 61 electoral votes would be enough to put the compact into force.
Critics and supporters
The Electoral College has many critics as well as supporters, who see it as a crucial component of the system of checks and balances designed by the Founding Fathers. The reality is that when they laid the foundations of the American republic, they could not have foreseen the central role political parties would come to play, since they did not yet exist, nor the extent to which the system would evolve into a rigid two-party structure.
The current system allows a president to be elected without winning the popular vote. Both George W. Bush and Donald Trump reached the White House despite receiving fewer votes nationwide than their opponents, Al Gore and Hillary Clinton, in the 2000 and 2016 elections.
Combined with the overrepresentation of less populous states, the Electoral College tends to favor Republicans, whose support is concentrated in states that wield disproportionate influence relative to their share of the national popular vote.
This is one reason why presidential elections increasingly appear to be decided in advance, with only a handful of states truly in play. In 2024, there were seven such battleground states, and Trump carried every one of them: Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Nevada and North Carolina.
If enacted, the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact could face legal challenges on the grounds that it may violate the Constitution’s Compact Clause. Found in Article I, Section 10, the clause provides that no state may enter into an agreement or compact with another state, or with a foreign power, without the consent of Congress.
This route to changing the Electoral College system is easier than pursuing a constitutional amendment, but it is also more fragile. Just as states can join the compact, they can also withdraw from it, for example, if Republicans regain control of state government.
Nor is it a given that demographic trends will always favor Democrats. Population shifts in recent years have cost traditionally blue states residents while boosting the populations of red states.
Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition
November 11 is Veterans Day in the United States, but stetsons proliferated Wednesday in front of the Capitol. Politicians and business leaders from Texas and Arizona joined forces to demand immigration reform outside the landmark complex that houses both chambers of Congress, which will be under Democratic control starting in January. Familiar faces from the Senate, such as Arizona Senator Rubén Gallego, and from the House of Representatives, including Texas representatives Henry Cuellar, Vicente González, Joaquín Castro, Verónica Escobar, and Sylvia García, were present.
But there were also new faces, freshly elected on November 3, who have come to Washington hoping to shake up a Congress that for decades has been unable to pass immigration reform. JoAnna Mendoza, from Arizona, and Bobby Pulido, the former Tejano singer who was elected to represent Texas’s 15th district, were among them. “In the last election, on November 3, we sent a clear message: we are tired of cruelty and we are tired of corruption,” he said.
Pulido was one of the protagonists of the midterms that helped turn an emblematic Republican state blue — Texas became a key example of the Democrats’ sweeping success in the elections. In his region, arrests by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) have wreaked havoc on families and the economy. “I am married to a Mexican. My son is from a mixed-status family. We need to fix this. And I want to tell you that I have taken note of the members who are here right now. Count on my commitment to work on this tirelessly. This is extremely important,” he added.
Pulido introduced his colleague Leticia Gutiérrez, a previously unknown face in Washington who will be sworn in as a congresswoman in January after defeating the Republican candidate despite her campaign’s limited resources. Her 9th district is where Mexican national Lorenzo Salgado was killed in July by gunfire from an ICE agent. At the altar where he was honored, residents placed their stickers on election day to show they had voted with immigration policy in mind.
“We should not be spending money on these racist policies that keep targeting our working communities, like Lorenzo Salgado’s, who was killed in my Magnolia Park community. That is my neighborhood, and my family lives there. He was not just a father; he was everyone’s father. Enough. We need to move forward,” Gutiérrez said.
Rejection of the Trump administration’s immigration policy was decisive in the Republican defeat in the midterms, and Democrats want to use the majorities they will enjoy in both chambers to push for a reform that would make it easier to legalize undocumented immigrants who have lived in the country for years.
Joaquín Castro, the representative from San Antonio, Texas, said “change is on the way.” In January, “we will have a Republican president — President Trump — and a Congress with a strong Democratic presence. This is an opportunity to address the issue of immigration reform. It is an opportunity to be true to the history of this country. History tells us that our nation became the most powerful and prosperous on Earth not in spite of immigrants, but because of them. I want us to legislate along those lines,” he said.
Deal with Trump
Rubén Gallego, for his part, recalled how the Latino vote was crucial in delivering victory to the Democrats, largely because of the harassment they face due to the racial profiling used in the deportation campaign.
“Latinos are giving Democrats the chance to win their vote back. And, in part, that requires us to push hard for immigration reform. That includes the possibility of reaching an agreement with Donald Trump,” the senator said.
Latinos voted en masse against the Republicans after a portion of their electorate switched parties in 2024 to support Trump’s return to the White House.
In an interview on CBS’s 60 Minutes on Sunday, the president acknowledged that his immigration policy had been too harsh, resulting in the deportation of many migrants who had worked and paid taxes in the U.S. for years. However, the appointment of Stephen Miller — an advocate of the hardest line — as chief of staff sent contradictory signals about his intentions.
Among the business leaders demonstrating in front of the Capitol was Mario Guerrero, president of the South Texas Builders Association. His sector is one of the most-affected by the labor shortage caused by ICE arrests.
Guerrero is one of the Republicans who, after voting for Trump three times, chose to cast his vote for the Democrats. “To the Republicans: understand that we’ve lost the party; you lost Texas, you lost the Latino vote, you lost the House of Representatives and the Senate. It’s time for President Trump to step aside so we can get real results. Every election is important, but these were historic. Texas has gone Democratic,” he said. And he issued a warning: “A friendly reminder to my friends in the Democratic Party: don’t mess with us. And don’t squander this opportunity, like Biden and Obama did.”
Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition