Spain has spent the past few weeks dealing with intense pressure on its borders, while just across the water, a very different border has been dramatically opened up.
Gibraltar’s land frontier with Spain disappeared on July 15 under the new UK-EU agreement, moving Schengen immigration controls to the Rock’s airport and port. For British expats living on the Costa del Sol, that should mean easier journeys into Gibraltar. Yet Spanish security officers are warning that quicker crossings must not come at the cost of proper border controls.
The timing is particularly interesting. Spain has recently faced a major migration crisis in Ceuta, where tens of thousands of people crossed from Morocco, putting enormous pressure on Spanish authorities, and the events in Ceuta have put border security firmly back in the spotlight. That makes one question increasingly relevant: could Gibraltar’s new system create opportunities for people trying to reach the Schengen area illegally?
Guardia Civil warns that security cannot be sacrificed
Olaya Salardon, communications secretary of the Asociación Unificada de la Guardia Civil, has warned that officers need much greater clarity about how the new Gibraltar arrangements will work. “Our concern is not the fence itself, but that security does not become a bargaining chip,” she said. Spanish officers want (and still don’t have) clear information about responsibilities, protocols and which authorities will take charge of particular border and security operations.
That matters because the old physical frontier has not simply disappeared without replacement. Schengen controls have moved to Gibraltar’s airport and port, where Spanish officials and Frontex are involved under the new arrangements.
Salardon has warned that any gaps in security could benefit organised criminal groups rather than ordinary citizens. For British expats who regularly travel between Spain and Gibraltar, that concern is not just theoretical. A border that is quicker to cross is only an improvement if travellers can also have confidence in the system protecting it.
Gibraltar says it must not become a back door into Schengen
Gibraltar’s Chief Minister Fabian Picardo has also addressed the issue directly. He has argued that the Rock should not be regarded simply as a convenient gateway into the Schengen area. “There has to be an economic relationship with Gibraltar, you have to contribute to Gibraltar loyally,” Picardo said, while also stressing that Gibraltar should not be seen “simply as a door to enter the Schengen area more easily”.
His comments take on added relevance after the recent events in Ceuta. Spanish authorities were faced with a huge influx of people arriving from Morocco, leading to a major security operation and agreements on returning migrants. The episode demonstrated just how quickly pressure can build around Spain’s external borders.
Gibraltar is a completely different situation, and there is no suggestion that the Ceuta events are linked to the Rock. However, both cases underline why control of Europe’s external borders remains such a sensitive issue.
What does this mean for British expats?
For British residents in Spain, the most visible change is likely to be much easier movement by road. Cars travelling between La Linea and Gibraltar no longer face the old routine land-border checks, removing one of the biggest frustrations for commuters, shoppers and visitors. Brexit rules have not, however, disappeared.
British citizens are still subject to the relevant Schengen entry requirements when entering the Schengen area unless they benefit from specific residence or other rights. The new Gibraltar arrangement does not turn a British passport into an EU passport or restore general freedom of movement. That distinction could become increasingly important as people get used to the new border.
Security is not the only issue British expats will notice. Gibraltar has introduced a new Transaction Tax as part of the customs arrangements linked to the treaty. The standard rate started at 15 per cent, with more changes due under the agreed timetable. Gibraltar’s government has also had to correct claims that the new tax automatically means shop prices will rise by 15 per cent.
Officials say the tax is based on the value of goods when imported or produced rather than simply being added to the final price paid by customers. Tobacco, alcohol and fuel are also covered by new arrangements intended to reduce tax differences with Spain and tackle smuggling. For expats who regularly cross the border to shop or fill the car, those changes could eventually be just as noticeable as the disappearance of the old frontier.
The fence has gone: Now the system faces its first real test
Gibraltar’s new border is supposed to make life easier for thousands of people who cross between the Rock and Spain every day. Yet the real test will be whether faster movement can be delivered while maintaining effective immigration, customs and criminal controls.
The Guardia Civil wants reassurance that security will not be sacrificed. Picardo insists Gibraltar should not become an easy gateway into Schengen. Spain’s recent experience in Ceuta shows why those questions matter.
New Developments2 weeks ago
Uncategorized2 weeks ago
Latest2 weeks ago