Francisco Pérez, wearing a hard hat and carrying a flashlight, has spent the past week outside the parking garage of a building that no longer exists. Somewhere beneath the rubble, several meters underground, is the car belonging to the woman he treats as his mother — his boss, Nancy Rojas, 67. He believes she is still inside.
Francisco says he managed to determine roughly where the vehicle might be and shouted questions down to her. According to him, she answered by knocking twice on the roof of the car for “yes” and three times for “no.” Others tried to convince him it could have been any noise. He refused to believe it. One knock, he said, could be a falling stone; three had to be Nancy calling for help.
Day after day, he returned to speak to Nancy, who used to call him “son,” but he has not heard her again. Given the condition of the building, rescuing her now seems impossible. The structure is so unstable that moving a single slab could bring the rest crashing down. Until Monday, he still had hope.
A week after the twin earthquakes plunged Venezuela into yet another unimaginable crisis, Delcy Rodríguez’s government has declared a week of national mourning, with the official death toll standing at 2,295 and the number of injured at 11,267. On Tuesday, however, National Assembly President Jorge Rodríguez suggested that the number of fatalities could be as high as 10,000. More body bags are on the way.
Meanwhile, a platform run by supporters of opposition leader María Corina Machado — an unofficial channel that often duplicates cases already reported elsewhere — says 40,668 people are “out of contact” with relatives. Authorities report damage to 855 buildings, 189 of which have totally collapsed. They are just numbers in a country that will spend months counting and burying its dead.
Francisco has felt so powerless that for days he told anyone willing to listen that the woman trapped beneath the rubble was his mother, even though she was not.
“It was the only way to get anyone to pay attention,” he confesses. “People, when I said she was my mom and they saw how desperate I was, came to help… That’s why the lie went so far.”
Seven days after the earthquakes, Francisco no longer talks about rescuing his boss. He talks about recovering her body. And burying it with dignity.
The vigil kept by the 28-year-old and his friend Scarly Rojas, Nancy’s only daughter, has become part of a ritual repeated day and night across La Guaira.
In the early hours of the morning, when there is less traffic and machinery noise, dozens of damaged buildings fall silent while rescuers — sometimes professionals, sometimes simply neighbors — call for quiet in hopes of hearing voices or knocks from beneath the debris. It is the same code Francisco used, repeated across an entire city.
Makeshift camps dot the area. Mattresses line the entrances of shattered residential complexes. People sleep there every night despite the overwhelming stench of decomposing bodies that now hangs over much of the municipality. And as long as that routine continues — as long as every night still carries even the faintest possibility of hearing something — it is difficult for an entire city to accept whatever comes next after the catastrophe.
On Tuesday, Scarly approached someone wearing a shirt emblazoned with the word “psychologist.” “I spoke to him because I also happen to be a psychiatric patient,” she explains. “I suffer from anxiety, and throughout all of this I’m still in shock. I haven’t really been able to process it or cry.”
Francisco remains stunned as well. He barely reacts and shows little emotion, but he is beginning to come to terms with reality. “Right now what’s left for me is to recover the body, give it a burial and go on with my life,” he says.
Outside another collapsed building, he stands with two young men whose girlfriends — sisters — remain buried beneath the rubble. Together they describe the wall preventing them from moving forward: they simply want to bury their dead.
“The hardest thing is that two days ago I had to do grocery shopping and it hit me hard,” Francisco tells them. “I kept thinking: ‘Damn, I’m doing something from ordinary life while my mom [referring to Nancy] is down there.’ And I can’t.”
Andrés Piñero, whose Spanish girlfriend Franchesca is one of the women still trapped inside, nods. “That’s what we want. To bury her, at least.”
Even for families who have already recovered a loved one’s body, grief is obstructed by countless hurdles: moving from one morgue to another — some of them improvised in open-air spaces — trying to find the deceased, identify them, fill out paperwork, and arrange cremation.
Hundreds of bodies have spent days exposed to the Caribbean heat — in parking lots, vacant lots and at the port.
“Some are already unrecognizable,” says a member of Delcy Rodríguez’s government in the disaster zone.
When possible, identification is carried out through personal belongings, tattoos or dental records. When it is not, families find themselves trapped in a different kind of limbo than Francisco’s: they have a body, but no certainty that it belongs to their loved one. Given the scale of the death toll, cremations cannot wait.
The desperation to reach relatives has driven some people to bypass the authorities, who are slow to arrive. José Mesa’s daughter and her grandparents remain trapped beneath the rubble of a building that leans a little farther each day. This week he climbed onto the roof himself, hoping to pull them out with his bare hands.
“It was a bit difficult because we didn’t have the materials. We need someone to climb up and help us,” he says.
But seven days after the earthquake, rescue teams remain focused on a different priority: the living, not the dead. Like Francisco, Mesa is waiting his turn.
Members of international rescue teams deployed to Venezuela say that sense of helplessness has produced a phenomenon increasingly visible on social media: survivors crawling into rubble and filming themselves pretending to be trapped, hoping the videos will go viral and draw rescuers to the exact building where their loved ones remain buried. They lie so that someone will come to help.
In Venezuela — a country where even in ordinary times many people live day to day — almost nobody is talking about the future yet.
“Maybe one day you recover,” Francisco says, “but for months afterward you’ll walk into a hardware store, see a pickaxe or a shovel, and it’ll all come back to you.”
For now, neither he nor anyone else can afford to think that far ahead. There is still searching to do.
Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition
Dr. Romero remembers that the woman arrived “walking like a little penguin and dripping.” She had just given birth on her own and still had pieces of the placenta inside her. Two nurses rushed her into surgery, and an operation began to prevent her from bleeding to death.
Using a cannula, Dr. Romero carefully removed the remaining tissue and, in less than an hour, extracted it all with precision Kocher forceps.
It was not the first time Romero had performed such a procedure, but it was the first time he had done so in temperatures above 40°C (104°F), in the dark, illuminated only by the nurses’ cellphones, and while operating on a McDonald’s stool.
The fast-food restaurant has been turned into a field hospital amid the devastation in La Guaira, at the epicenter of Venezuela’s earthquake disaster. The makeshift facility, set up by volunteer doctors and supplied through donations from civil society, has become a symbol of the extreme needs, institutional abandonment and improvised response that persist a week after the worst natural disaster to strike Venezuela in more than a century.
The window of hope for finding survivors beneath the rubble is growing ever narrower, but the toll of the disaster continues to rise. One week on, the death toll has surpassed 1,900, with more than 10,000 people injured. According to the Venezuelan government, which issues brief daily updates with few details, 855 buildings have been affected, of which 189 have suffered a total collapse.
Jorge Rodríguez, the president of the National Assembly and the official leading the government’s sparse daily briefings, announced on Tuesday that 50 camps have been set up on the outskirts of the capital to shelter survivors. Authorities have also improvised eight new morgues, where bodies are piling up.
At the port of La Guaira, hundreds of bodies await identification by relatives, who queue for hours in lines stretching for blocks. While waiting to enter the port facilities, many rummage through mountains of clothing piled up in the street, searching for possessions recovered from the disaster.
The coastal state has borne the brunt of the disaster, with tourist towers more than 10 stories high reduced to mountains of rubble and countless victims buried beneath them. But there are also poorer neighborhoods where little, if any, aid has arrived.
The U.N. Refugee Agency (UNHCR) said on Tuesday that there has been a “dramatic surge in humanitarian and protection needs” in the hardest-hit areas, citing severe food shortages, the collapse of basic services and growing protection risks for displaced people.
In the face of the government’s inadequate response, a final-year medical student from Caracas who arrived in the disaster zone during the first days set up a makeshift clinic “with a blanket and two tarps tied to a tree” near the McDonald’s abandoned after the earthquake.
One of his first patients was a police officer suffering from low blood pressure.
“We stabilized him and I took the opportunity to ask him to let us use the restaurant so we could work in better conditions,” he says outside the building, which is cordoned off with yellow police tape.
The arrangement was that the doctors would be allowed inside while police officers would provide security against theft and looting, which have become increasingly common in the hardest-hit areas.
They gained access on Saturday and, the following day, after clearing away debris, converted the building into a functioning medical facility. The operating room — where they treated the woman who had just given birth — was installed in the first-floor dining area. The pharmacy was set up beside the counter where hamburgers were once served. Upstairs became a rest area, filled with worn mattresses where doctors and nurses can sleep.
Relations with the police have not always been easy. The student, who serves as a liaison with the officers, says he trusts “only the commanders.”
“The rank-and-file officers try to take advantage of the tragedy,” he says.
In the dining area, doctors have hung IV bags and vitamin drips from the ceiling using bandages. With an IV line in his right arm, Officer Nelson Guerrero, a heavyset 52-year-old, explains that he asked medical staff to administer insulin because he has only one kidney following a traffic accident.
“We’re here to stop people from taking advantage, to make sure nobody does what they shouldn’t,” he says, as the drip delivers insulin and sweat runs down his forehead.
Tension
Inside the McDonald’s-turned-hospital, the atmosphere is even more tense than usual. The medical team has just been warned that the building next door — a massive pastel-colored apartment block with more than 100 units that is still standing — is on the verge of completely collapsing.
It is one of the public housing projects built by the Chávez government under the Misión Vivienda housing program for low-income families. Residents recall that when former president Hugo Chávez came to inaugurate the complex more than two decades ago, he invoked a famous line from his political hero. During reconstruction efforts after the devastating 1812 earthquake that struck Caracas, Simón Bolívar declared: “If nature opposes us, we will fight against it and make it obey us.” Chávez repeated the same messianic rallying cry after the deadly mudslides that devastated this very region in 1999, the first major disaster his movement faced after coming to power.
“It seems we’re cursed,” says one resident, his face covered with a T-shirt to shield himself from the sun and the stench of decay.
The government of Delcy Rodríguez, which has been under U.S. supervision since president Nicolás Maduro’s capture in January, is also facing its first major test. Public frustration, already stretched to the limit, is growing by the day. With thousands of armed soldiers and police officers deployed across the disaster zone, the risk of social unrest is a latent threat with unpredictable consequences.
“We have had no news from the government. They certainly aren’t supporting us here,” says Dr. Miguel Romero, the surgeon leading the field hospital, although responsibility for directing operations rotates among the medical teams when they head out into the field.
Romero, 34, is pursuing a doctorate in neurology in Germany. He arrived in Venezuela one day before the earthquake to visit family in Coro, a coastal city. Since reaching the disaster zone after a bus journey of more than 10 hours, he has slept only a couple of hours a day.
The McDonald’s pharmacy is well stocked, the doctors say. It has intravenous painkillers, surgical supplies, anti-anxiety medications and even veterinary drugs, used to treat pets in the parking lot, where until a few days ago customers drove through to pick up their Big Macs.
Upstairs, the restaurant is also housing international rescue teams with nowhere else to spend the night. More than 2,300 specialists have arrived from countries including Mexico, China, Spain and Qatar.
Monday night was particularly difficult. It rained in La Guaira for the first time since the disaster, something many had expected given that it is the rainy season. The sky had been forgiving until then. Rain and mud have made everything even harder.
But Dr. Ramírez, who is close to completing his studies in Germany, remains hopeful: “I trust in the strength, resilience and stoicism of a people mobilized and clinging to life.”
Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition
El presidente del Parlamento venezolano, Jorge Rodríguez, ha comunicado este martes, seis días después del doble terremoto que sacudió el norte del país el pasado miércoles, que la cifra de fallecidos por la catástrofe se sitúa ya en 1.943 personas y la de heridos en 10.571. Se trata de una brusca subida en ambas cifras con respecto al día anterior: un alza de 224 muertos y de más de 5.500 heridos. Del total de víctimas mortales, 19 son españoles, según ha informado el ministro de Asuntos Exteriores de España, José Manuel Albares, que ha añadido que sigue habiendo 131 desaparecidos y 12 localizados bajo los escombros. Los daños causados por los dos terremotos en viviendas y activos económicos, como vehículos, edificios o comercios, tienen una estimación preliminar de 6.700 millones de dólares (5.800 millones de euros), según una evaluación satelital basada en el Análisis Digital Rápido del Programa de Naciones Unidas para el Desarrollo (PNUD). Las autoridades venezolanas han informado de que hay 855 edificios afectados, de los cuales 189 han sufrido “un colapso total”.
“It has been utter despair.” Eduardo Campos was driving to work with the radio on when the first morning bulletin reported on the Venezuela earthquake disaster. He pulled over onto the shoulder and sent a WhatsApp message that never went through. Since then, this resident of Marín, in the northwestern Spanish region of Galicia, has done the only thing he could from 4,000 miles away: tell his neighbors’ story to anyone who would listen. To acquaintances in the military, to a cousin in Panama, to his son, a doctor living in Florida, and to the local press. He searched survivor lists for names, requested heavy machinery, asked about a satellite antenna to help locate them amid the rubble. And on Sunday he called EL PAÍS: “Help me get them out of there.”
In a forgotten corner of La Guaira, the ground zero of last Wednesday’s double earthquake, a family from Marín remains trapped: Yhosvany Hernández, the coach of the hockey club where Campos’s son plays; his wife, Adela Taberneiro, the club president; and the couple’s two children, Lía, nine, and Ulises, eight. Buried alongside them are the grandparents, Carmen Rosa Fernández and Roger Hernández, who were hosting the family during their visit to the Venezuelan city wedged between the Caribbean and the mountains.
The Hernández Taberneiro family had emigrated to Galicia seven years ago, and this was their first visit back to Venezuela since leaving.
Civilians and authorities working to clear debris in La Guaira on June 28.Chelo CamachoA rescue team iworking to recover a body from the rubble at the OPP 33 building.Chelo CamachoRescue teams from around the world have arrived in Venezuela to assist with the search efforts.Chelo CamachoMembers of a French rescue team working in the ruins of a building.Chelo CamachoA man breaks through the rebar of a collapsed building in La Guaira.Chelo CamachoCivilians working day and night through the rubble of the OPP 33 building in search of their loved ones.Chelo Camacho
“He had to take the children away so they could have a better education; those were his words,” recalls his sister. They had return tickets for July 16, but they are now four of the 138 Spanish citizens — the family held dual nationality — listed as missing after Venezuela was struck by two earthquakes.
So far, 17 Spaniards have been confirmed dead. Spanish sources in Caracas warn that those figures are little more than a preliminary accounting and are likely to rise significantly. The overall death toll reached 1,450 on Sunday, while tens of thousands of people remain unaccounted for.
The six of them were celebrating their reunion that Wednesday afternoon. It was also the birthday of both the grandfather and the children’s father. They were all gathered around the dining table in the second-floor apartment — a floor that nobody now knows how to locate beneath the rubble. The tower collapsed forward.
Until Sunday, not a single excavator had reached the modest, devastated neighborhood where the grandparents lived. Standing outside the ruined building since Wednesday is Mabel Hernández, Yhosvany’s sister. She sleeps out in the open on a vacant lot where an old stranded boat is rotting. Some residents have laid out mattresses and blankets there so they can keep watch over the mountain of concrete they are trying to dismantle with their bare hands.
It was Mabel who had arranged the family reunion. Eight months earlier, she had brought her parents from Cuba, and the family tried to get together every year on June 23 and 24, the birthdays of her father and her brother.
“In the end it was like a farewell,” she says. Faced with the tragedy, the woman has one consolation. By sheer chance, her son and his wife, who had been at the celebration, survived. They had stepped outside for a cigarette. “The children are here and I don’t want to smoke in front of them,” the wife had said. The building collapsed while they were on the street. They escaped unharmed.
Her desperation over the rescue effort mirrors that of thousands of Venezuelans these days. “I’ve been here since Wednesday and they have done nothing,” says Mabel, who is demanding heavy machinery to break through the cement and reach her loved ones.
Everyone around her feels the same way: powerless and near collapse. Rescue workers, she says, “come looking for life, but when they don’t hear anything they leave.” Beyond the 72-hour mark, which passed on Saturday, the chances of finding survivors diminish dramatically.
A second excavator arrived after the first, but it cannot operate because there is no fuel. “They lent us a machine, but there is no diesel to put in it. How can they tell me there is no diesel in this country for the machine?” she asks. “Venezuela has no resources, despite being a very [oil] rich country.”
The tower where her parents lived was part of a public housing complex that collapsed entirely. Unlike the wealthier residential developments, with their swimming pools and better construction, these buildings were reduced to rubble. It is also the area where the fewest rescue workers and machines are visible, where residents dig through the debris until their hands bleed, working day and night by the light of their cell phones.
Utter helplessness
The sense of helplessness is overwhelming because many already fear it is too late. That only a miracle could save those still trapped. “If they died, it was because of negligence. I’m sure of it,” Mabel says through her tears. “There’s nothing here. Everything is for them, everything is about making money, everything is about being seen on camera and nothing more,” she says of authorities she feels have abandoned them.
Until Saturday, Mabel still allowed herself to believe her family might emerge alive from beneath the rubble. At night, lying in the vacant lot, she would tell herself they were still breathing: “You know when you just feel something? Up until yesterday, I kept saying they were alive. My father is 84, but the children could hold on a little longer.” Today, she weeps and asks only for a hug.
Meanwhile, in Marín, Eduardo struggles with the anguish of distance and the lack of information. He came to know the family through the children. His son and Ulises became friends in their first year of primary school. Both were shy, similar in temperament — “as thick as thieves, inseparable” for the past two years. When Eduardo started a hockey team at the school, Ulises was already playing, and the friendship carried over from the classroom to the rink.
The family had left Venezuela when Lía was two years old and Ulises had not yet turned one. This was the children’s first trip back to the country where they were born. They were “very, very excited,” Eduardo says.
On Friday, amid the confusion and uncertainty, reports emerged suggesting that the family had appeared on a list of survivors and were safe. The relief was short-lived. It turned out to be a mix-up involving a message from another Yhosvany — the coach’s son from a previous marriage, a doctor living in Florida.
He cannot bring himself to talk about it. “Remembering all that, I feel it would not do me any good right now, I’m sorry,” he says from the United States.
Edu, Eduardo’s six-year-old son, still does not know what has happened in Venezuela. On Friday in class, the children had to write the name of their best friend. Edu drew two figures: he wrote the name of another classmate under one, and Ulises under the other. “Honestly, I would almost prefer not to have any hope,” Eduardo laments. “On Saturday I couldn’t find a corner to cry in. I had to leave the house so I wouldn’t do it in front of the boy.”
Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition