Connect with us

Colombia

A Week After The Brooklyn Building Collapse, One Question Unites Victims And Investigators: ‘What Exactly Happened There?’

Published

on

a-week-after-the-brooklyn-building-collapse,-one-question-unites-victims-and-investigators:-‘what-exactly-happened-there?’

A Wednesday that changed everything; a collapsed building; eight families mourning their dead and a week in which Luis Siguencia has kept asking the same questions about the Brooklyn collapse that killed his son Gabriel: “What exactly happened there?” he says. “I see many comments saying that the construction had been halted and yet they were still working. Why? What caused that collapse?”

No authority, as of today, has approached Siguencia to brief him on the investigation led by the New York City Department of Buildings (DOB) into the collapse of the property at 1321 Flatbush Avenue. Two days earlier, Gabriel, a 22-year-old Ecuadorian, had begun working on the excavation of the adjacent lot, 2625 Bedford Avenue, before a wave of concrete fell on him, killing him and seven other migrant workers from Guatemala, Colombia, Ecuador and Guinea.

The tragedy has exposed several clashes in the city that is both the world’s most multicultural and one of its major financial centers: gentrification and rampant construction in neighborhoods such as Little Caribbean; residents’ complaints about rising rents; the vulnerability of construction workers, most of them immigrants; and the alleged tricks used by construction companies and building owners despite numerous complaints lodged with New York authorities.

What those affected want in the short term is clarity on several questions surrounding the disaster: What was the direct cause of the collapse? And when will an investigation shed light on the incident?

Ryan J. Degan, senior press officer at the DOB, told EL PAÍS that the investigation “is ongoing.” “We are working in close coordination with our law enforcement partners on their parallel investigations,” he told this newspaper. To assist the forensic probe, the city has hired an outside engineering firm to produce an independent investigative report, and inspections have begun on about 160 projects linked to six entities from the crew working on the excavations. For safety reasons, he said, the names of the six entities would not be disclosed.

Los familiares lloran en el velatorio de Gabriel Ariolfo Siguencia Yupa, de 22 años, fallecido en el derrumbe de un edificio de Brooklyn, en Brooklyn (Nueva York), el 16 de noviembre de 2026.

“It’s too early in the investigation to determine the cause of the collapse,” Degan says, “but these inspections are an important part of our ongoing inquiry and are being carried out in the interest of public safety.”

The day after the tragedy, under torrential rain that interrupted search-and-rescue efforts, Mayor Zohran Mamdani arrived at the spot on Flatbush Avenue and vowed to carry out “a thorough investigation.” “That includes both the site work and the building that collapsed,” he said.

Experts consulted by this newspaper say the results of an investigation could come as soon as two weeks or take up to two months. Meanwhile, several details that have emerged focus attention on one man and a history of violations, neglect and lawbreaking: Robert Fischman, the owner of the lot where the construction workers were excavating that led to one of the deadliest incidents in New York’s construction sector.

A long list of complaints, fines and tenant displacements

In the days after the collapse, many neighbors gathered in disbelief outside a building that could have been any one of theirs. It was the typical building in this Brooklyn neighborhood: three stories, brick facade and tall glass windows, with a business on the ground floor.

More than once, according to Dominican resident Eneroliza Pérez, they felt the neighborhood’s streets shake because of the construction work that was underway. Fischman intended to erect on the adjacent lot a structure that would initially be three stories tall, though the owner later sought to expand it to nine stories with 64 residential units, according to information provided by the DOB.

At first, the project team filed an application and obtained approvals and permits to carry out underground work associated with the three-story project. In other words, they were authorized to perform earthmoving, excavation shoring and foundation work. What the DOB never approved was a permit to build nine stories.

“At the time of the collapse, the application had been returned by the DOB with objections,” Degan says, adding that as part of the ongoing investigation they are reviewing whether the work was being performed in accordance with the approved plans.

Velatorio de Gabriel Ariolfo Siguencia Yupa, de 22 años, fallecido en el derrumbe de un edificio de Brooklyn, en Brooklyn (Nueva York), el 16 de noviembre de 2026.

This was not the only construction going on in the neighborhood. In this area of Brooklyn, many new buildings have been erected recently, some unaffordable to longtime residents. “Small buildings are being torn down and replaced by larger ones,” says George M. Janes, an urban planner and planning consultant in New York. He says access to housing began to tighten about 20 years ago. “In many of these neighborhoods, rising housing costs and the lack of affordable housing are making these areas increasingly unaffordable for many lifelong residents.”

Last June, Fischman sent a letter to the residents of 1321 Flatbush to inform them that the noisy excavation would become part of the neighborhood’s soundtrack. What Flatbush residents did not know was that construction would go ahead despite the owner having violated the law on two occasions.

On March 20, 2026, the DOB issued a stop-work order at the excavation site. After its inspectors found that the demolition of the existing building was being carried out without protective structures or nets to shield neighboring properties, the DOB fined the owner $2,500. The fine, Degan says, was paid.

Tarjetas de oración en el velatorio de Gabriel Ariolfo Siguencia Yupa, de 22 años, fallecido en el derrumbe de un edificio de Brooklyn, en Brooklyn (Nueva York), el 16 de noviembre de 2026.

In April, a second fine followed. When inspectors visited the site on April 23, 2026, they found demolition work had resumed, violating the city order. The owner was fined $10,000 for another violation.

In May, the DOB says the stop-work order was fully lifted “after the project team corrected all conditions that had led to the violations.”

The following month, in June, neighbors received another notice from Fischman announcing the resumption of work. Among them were residents of the adjoining building owned by Olufemi Falade, a man who in 2006 told The Village Voice: “How can an owner repair, if the tenant does not pay the rent?”

At the time he faced 12 days in jail for refusing to fix about 1,800 violations in other buildings he owned — he then had about 16 properties scattered across the city. The news outlet reported that several of his properties lacked hardware or windows, and some walls were crumbling. Records from the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development show complaints about the building that collapsed a week ago, a nearly 100-year-old structure, including “unsafe electrical wiring” and missing smoke detectors.

Awaiting an official response

Last Wednesday, José Luis Caguana, a 22-year-old Ecuadorian and soccer fan, and Gabriel Siguencia arrived early at the site where they were earning $35 an hour, one of their co-workers who escaped the tragedy told this newspaper. The rest of the fatalities were residents of 1321 Flatbush, including two Colombian children who had not attended school that Wednesday as it was a holiday, Veterans Day.

Bomberos atienden el edificio derrumbado en Brooklyn.

At 4.01 pm, the New York City Fire Department received the first emergency call. The building had collapsed. Neighbors say they only heard a roar, then a blinding cloud of dust and later the mountain of rubble on which firefighters worked for more than 24 continuous hours trying to save lives.

The day after the disaster, November 12, the DOB received an anonymous complaint asking it to investigate the excavation next to the collapsed building. “I am concerned that the subcontractor excavated too much soil along the adjacent foundation all at once,” the complaint said. It asked authorities to compare the city-approved plans with the work carried out on site. The plans contemplated excavating the soil at a 45-degree angle to a depth of approximately 4.5 meters.

“When you dig a deep hole, nearby buildings’ foundations can shift or become unstable. If the foundations become unstable, the whole building can collapse,” explains Anil K. Agrawal, professor and chair of the Department of Civil Engineering at The City College of New York.

Professor Agrawal says the impact of the excavation on the neighboring building should have been assessed, a common issue often overlooked because of insufficient attention to adjacent structures. When this type of excavation is carried out, he says, the soil around the foundations and the excavated area must be reinforced. “What we call shoring consists of creating an artificial wall to hold the ground in place. That way you ensure the soil does not shift and the foundations do not move. And that is something they did not do in this case.”

Colapso de la estructura del edificio.

The engineer insists that any investigation must focus on the foundations. “They may show signs that the soil moved,” he says. He also believes that when soil samples are taken, they will be able to determine how sturdy it was and whether there was any risk of collapse, and even whether the project’s engineer or contractor had previously performed such borings and soil tests.

Meanwhile, all parties are waiting: families await answers though nothing will console them; displaced neighbors need a place to live. And many other residents have been left fearful about the condition of the buildings they live in. Since the day of the collapse, the DOB has received 149 complaints that, officials say, reported concerns about buildings shaking or vibrating, and some were related to new construction. Unless everything is made safe, New Yorkers will not sleep peacefully again amid the rumble of excavators or the sight of a cracked ceiling overhead.

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition

Abelardo de la Espriella

Colombia’s Peace Tribunal Chief Warns Government Cuts Could Trigger International Criminal Court Scrutiny

Published

on

colombia’s-peace-tribunal-chief-warns-government-cuts-could-trigger-international-criminal-court-scrutiny

In Aeschylus’ Oresteia, Orestes kills his mother to avenge his father, whom his mother had murdered after he sacrificed their daughter. The Furies, goddesses of vengeance, pursue Orestes until Athena establishes a court to put him on trial, breaking the cycle of retribution.

Last week, Danilo Rojas Betancourth, 65, chose this myth for his inaugural speech as president of Colombia’s Special Jurisdiction for Peace (JEP), the tribunal established under the 2016 peace agreement between the Colombian government and the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC), the now-defunct guerrilla group. For him, this is the ultimate purpose of justice: to put an end to vengeance.

But he takes office at the worst possible moment for the institution. The government of Colombian President Abelardo de la Espriella has cut its budget by 170 billion pesos (around $52 million), forcing the JEP to leave its headquarters, move to remote working and scale back protection for victims, witnesses and judges. Meanwhile, a constitutional reform bill is making its way through Congress that would shut the tribunal down in 2028.

Who are the Furies today? The judge, a former president of Colombia’s Council of State, prefers not to name them. “I wish I knew who was behind it.”

Question. You have been chosen to lead a jurisdiction that the government has effectively marked for closure. Are you here to run the JEP or to manage its winding down?

Answer. Both. The JEP is already beginning to plan for its closure. It has resolved nearly 1,000 amnesty cases involving former guerrilla fighters and granted 1,070 decisions not to prosecute members of the military. By December 15, it will have issued its final indictments in the 11 major cases it is investigating. Next year, those indicted will decide whether or not to acknowledge responsibility. Those who do will face trials resulting in restorative sanctions. Those who do not will go to trial and could face prison sentences of up to 20 years.

Q. Can the JEP function with a budget cut of 170 billion pesos and 85% fewer contracts?

A. It is the most devastating blow the JEP has received in all these years. It forces us to undertake a complete restructuring. We will vacate these premises in March, with remote working becoming the norm and staff working on a rotating basis. We will have to scale back activities that were very important for victims. We have to change strategy.

Q. Did you expect such an aggressive assault?

A. No, of course not. But the JEP has a longstanding legitimacy problem, because the peace agreement lost the referendum. It was much like Brexit: it was close, but it lost. Since then, anything that happens at the JEP is accepted by half the country and resented by the other half.

Q. Is there an element of revenge in this offensive — in the budget cuts and the attempts to undermine the JEP’s legitimacy?

A. I don’t know whether revenge is the right word, but there has been a merciless ad hominem attack: the focus has been more on the person than on the arguments. My colleagues have been subjected to attacks that are false and malicious. The dignity of many people here has been undermined.

Q. Who is behind it?

A. I wish I knew. Some politicians have spoken out about it, but it’s very hard to know who might be behind it.

Q. The budget cuts affect security arrangements for the judges themselves, who are also targets of these attacks, as well as for victims, witnesses and those appearing before the JEP. How many people will lose their protection?

A. We are talking about almost 250 people whose security arrangements will have to be scaled back and reassessed. I don’t think they will be left without protection altogether; that would be very risky. I have repeatedly told the government that it must take responsibility for this.

Q. Almost 10 years on, there have been just two rulings. Was the JEP too ambitious?

A. I acknowledge that it was. In its effort to ensure that no one escaped justice, the JEP took on a broader remit. In my view, it could have been somewhat narrower. But when you reduce the number of people under investigation, you increase the scope for impunity. Our two rulings — on kidnapping and false positives [civilians killed by Colombian military personnel and falsely reported as guerrillas killed in combat] — cover an enormous number of incidents: the kidnapping ruling alone covers 21,000. It is not a ruling on a single case, but on thousands. There have also been decisions that are equivalent in substance to rulings, even if they are not formally called that: the 1,000 amnesties and the 1,070 decisions not to prosecute.

Q. With today’s perspective, what would you have done differently?

A. I would have opened only four cases: the FARC case, the security forces case, the case of civilians involved in the war and the case of state agents such as congresspeople, governors and mayors. Those appearing before the JEP and the victims would not have had to attend different cases, but just one. But the qualitative aspects are harder to measure. This process produces genuine reconciliation. Admitting responsibility is not easy. Doing so in front of a victim, in relation to serious harm inflicted on them, is immensely valuable.

Q. What do you say to those who believe that planting trees or painting a mural is not a punishment enough for crimes such as kidnapping and false positives?

A. The JEP did not invent these sanctions; they were established in the peace agreement. No state can bring every perpetrator of mass harm to justice, so a transitional arrangement has to be agreed: a small number are tried, and they answer for all the crimes. That is what could happen in Ukraine or Gaza when the time comes to establish accountability. Here, the decision was: no prison, but a sanction that restricts freedom and restores lives. What is sometimes so readily dismissed — a mural, a tree-planting project, a mine-clearance operation — is very transformative for the victim, because that is the kind of sanction they asked for.

Q. Do all victims see it that way?

A. No, and that is entirely understandable. There are victims who have every right to say: “What I want is for this person to rot in prison.”

Q. Some of your colleagues argue that the real aim of shortening the JEP’s mandate is to prevent the trials of the 29 military officers who refused to acknowledge their crimes, almost all of them generals. Do you share that view?

A. There is a group of generals who did not admit responsibility, and our small prosecution office has until March 14, 2028, to charge them. I would seriously doubt that this project seeks to obstruct that, because doing so would mean empowering the ordinary justice system and changing everything the peace agreement set out to achieve. And if charges could not be brought because the timeframe had been cut short, the International Criminal Court’s preliminary examination could be reopened. That is a risk.

Q. The JEP is constitutionally guaranteed to remain in place until 2033. If Congress passes the bill, will you take the matter to the Constitutional Court?

A. I would hope it would not have to reach the Constitutional Court, that Congress would stop the process. A law that shortens the timeframe and changes the court with jurisdiction over the cases is not consistent with the peace agreement. But if it passes, I am in favor of going to the Constitutional Court.

Q. And would you appeal to international bodies, even if that put a strain on relations with the government?

A. Scrutiny by the Office of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court will be unavoidable. The government of Iván Duque signed a cooperation agreement with the ICC prosecutor that expressly states that the JEP’s budget must not be affected and that its legal framework must not be changed. That is precisely what has been done in budgetary terms and what they are now seeking to do in legal terms.

Q. Anyone looking at Colombia today would see anything but the end of a war. Where are we now?

A. The FARC disappeared. There has not been a single attack by that guerrilla movement in 10 years. Dissident groups, deserters and criminal groups such as the Clan del Golfo remain, which have gained ground because the state failed to take control of those areas. It is a new war, but completely different from the one waged by the FARC, which did aspire to seize power.

Q. Will the government’s hard-line approach to bringing armed groups under its authority work?

A. I hope it works. But the bill on the submission of armed groups to justice draws heavily on the restorative justice system, which is our area of expertise. It does not provide for prison sentences behind bars, but rather detention in agricultural colonies, and it sets conditions requiring perpetrators to tell the truth and help locate the disappeared.

Q. Colombia’s ambassador to the United Nations, Mauricio Gaona, said the peace agreement is not a model for the world. Was it necessary to go that far?

A. Gaona was simply doing what his role requires, in line with the government. All the countries that intervened before were generous, including the United States. The discrepancy is glaring.

Q. Are you concerned that, when the JEP closes, its legacy may not be what you hoped for?

A. Over time, it will become clearer. It seems we may need to go through another experience for people to see how well we did things here. The victims were treated very well: not only did they take part in the process, but the psychosocial support provided to people who had suffered so much was also very important. And I am convinced that this model can be useful beyond Colombia. There are heads of state responsible for mass atrocities who will never go to prison. When they operate at that level, a way forward has to be found. And that way forward is: no prison, but they must accept responsibility. Accepting responsibility is not easy.

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition

Continue Reading

Colombia

‘We Work Like Slaves In This Country And They Don’t Give Us Safety’: Anger And Grief After Brooklyn Building Collapse

Published

on

By

‘we-work-like-slaves-in-this-country-and-they-don’t-give-us-safety’:-anger-and-grief-after-brooklyn-building-collapse

Walter Sinche looks a little agitated as he arrives at the intersection of Bedford and Flatbush avenues. He is wearing a plaid shirt and a red poncho that shields him from the heavy downpour hitting Brooklyn on Thursday at noon. José Luis Caguana, 26, an Ecuadorian man like him, was one of his students in training courses at OSHA—the federal agency that oversees occupational safety and health standards—and is now one of the identified victims after the collapse on Wednesday of a residential building in the heart of Brooklyn.

The incident has placed the spotlight on construction practices in the city, and triggered both fear and anger among local residents of this largely immigrant community. Eight people, including two children ages nine and 10, died as a result of the sudden collapse, which took place as excavation work was going on at a construction site next door. Two of the victims were workers at the site, including Sinche’s former student, the 26-year-old José Luis Caguana Cosquillo.

Another 18 people sustained injuries, and one is in critical condition. Affected individuals include immigrants from Mexico, Colombia, Ecuador and Trinidad, said Mayor Zohran Mamdani, speaking at the site of the accident. The Colombian consulate in New York on Thursday confirmed that the two minors were Colombian nationals, as was one of the deceased adults. Another Colombian woman is on the list of injured victims, officials added.

By the time Sinche reached the scene, the mayor had already arrived and begun his briefing to a group of reporters. Sinche wanted to confront the mayor about his responsibility in the death of one of their own. “I wanted to tell him to do his job better,” he says, visibly upset. “We are the ones who put our bodies on the line. We work day after day like slaves in this country and they don’t give us safety.” But Sinche could not reach Mamdani. A police officer blocked his path and would not let him advance to where the mayor stood surrounded by reporters from the city’s major outlets.

Caguana had arrived in the United States from Ambato, in Tungurahua province, Ecuador, about six years earlier. His wife, with whom he had a four-year-old son, is about to give birth. The child’s teachers at the Bushwick United Headstart center described Caguana as a “loving and devoted” father. “His love for his children was evident,” they said in a GoFundMe campaign to raise funds for the family.

Two years earlier, Caguana took a class with Sinche to start working in construction. Among everything Sinche teaches his students, there is one thing he insists on: “Demand safety,” he tells them. “And if they don’t give you safety, don’t work.”

But Wednesday’s accident goes beyond an individual worker’s responsibility, says the OSHA inspector. Building 1321 on Flatbush Avenue collapsed into a hole created by nearby construction and caused a side wall of the adjacent property to fall. That, Sinche says, is a responsibility that exceeds construction workers. “It’s not just that they didn’t give you a hard hat or gloves,” he says. “Whether a building collapses no longer depends on the worker, but on the authorities that oversee this kind of work. Therefore it is the responsibility of the Department of Buildings, the company owners and the supervisors. They are responsible; they should be jailed.”

On Thursday the entire area was filled with dozens of local residents stunned by an incident whose causes are still under investigation. The questions are piling up as time passes and new lines of inquiry open for the city: did the excavation weaken the building’s foundations or walls? Which company was responsible for the work? Had any warnings been issued that something like this could happen?

“Our lives are not cheap”

Flatbush residents’ anger was evident. Kamela Payne lives in the area and, if she had to sum up what has happened, she would put it this way: “I think our city has been sold, honestly,” she says. She believes the Department of Buildings, which is supposed to oversee this kind of construction, is not doing an appropriate job.

“I think some of these developers are putting economic pressure on some of these people and organizations,” Payne says. “Our lives are not cheap, and I consider this an act of criminality. These people didn’t stand a chance. They didn’t know they would wake up in the morning and have their entire building come down on them. That says a lot about New York City. A family can wake up and end up underground. This is not a developing country.”

“We have to investigate the Department of Buildings and make sure the people who must assume responsibility are held accountable,” adds Payne, who has lived in the neighborhood for more than three decades. “These people excavated under the foundations and caused other people’s deaths. That is a crime. This is not simply a mistake.”

A friend accompanying Payne is convinced that what is happening in this area and in much of New York is related to the displacement of Black residents. Two brand-new buildings stand near the collapsed structure. “They’re building apartments that we can’t afford, what they call affordable housing. It’s not affordable if a two-bedroom apartment costs $3,000 a month,” the woman says.

“It’s very sad, doubly so now that the Christmas holidays are approaching,” says Eneroliza Pérez, a Dominican woman who says the tragedy has dealt a blow to a community also known as Little Caribbean, where many Dominicans and Haitians live. Her family runs the deli directly across from the collapsed building, opposite where a crowd of people remains gathered, still stunned by such a tragedy in the heart of Brooklyn.

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition

Continue Reading

Abelardo de la Espriella

Sex-For-Contracts Allegations Rock Gustavo Petro And Colombia’s Left

Published

on

sex-for-contracts-allegations-rock-gustavo-petro-and-colombia’s-left

Gustavo Petro’s private life has become the focus of public debate in Colombia. The allegations against the former president have left Colombia’s left-wing opposition in a difficult position. Back in opposition after Petro’s presidency and now holding the largest bloc in Congress, albeit well short of a majority, it is trying to resist the offensive launched by the far-right government of Abelardo de la Espriella.

But the accusations, which claim that Petro awarded public contracts to women in exchange for sex, have opened a Pandora’s box over practices both in the previous administration and within the Pacto Histórico (Historic Pact), the left-wing coalition that united Petro’s supporters into a single party, where tensions between different factions are beginning to show.

The left finds itself caught between loyalty to Petro and a desire to distance itself from him. While many on the left insist on due process and the presumption of innocence, calls for introspection and self-criticism are growing, particularly over what critics see as a betrayal of the feminist principles the movement once championed.

The allegations go beyond the private life of the first left-wing president in modern Colombian history. Deicy Jiménez, a 26-year-old woman who received several state contracts during the previous administration, claimed last month that the 66-year-old former president set up a network of women whom he rewarded with public jobs in exchange for sexual relationships. Shortly afterwards, she released a video showing the two kissing. Since then, additional videos and chat messages have been leaked to the media.

Petro has denied the allegations, though not his relationship with Jiménez, who is 40 years his junior, and has said he will defend himself “before the courts,” rather than on social media, his preferred means of communication. Even so, he took to X on Monday to respond to what he described as a “false narrative.”

The head of President Abelardo de la Espriella’s Administrative Department of the Presidency, known as Dapre, has claimed that the network involved more than 40 women, though he has provided no further details or evidence, and the allegations remain under investigation. Beyond feminist criticism, the right has found a political gold mine in the former president’s scandal-ridden sex life and has seized on it to mount relentless attacks on his character and morality.

Last week, Noticias Caracol published a chat exchange from late 2025 in which Petro appears to ask the then head of Dapre to renew a contract for Deicy Jiménez at the Interior Ministry. Jiménez also held contracts with the Superintendency of Surveillance and with then-government senator María José Pizarro, who has said the accuser should be heard “with every guarantee” of due process.

Journalist María Jimena Duzán added to the controversy by writing in a column that at least 10 sources had described “getaways” with Petro involving “prostitutes, transvestites and friends who supplied him with hallucinogenic substances.” “Many of the people who attended his parties were paid with contracts to buy their silence,” Duzán wrote, without identifying her sources.

At a politically inopportune moment for internal divisions, the scandal has dealt a significant blow to Colombia’s left. Throughout his long political career, Petro, who has often been inclined to dominate the spotlight, has also been something of a politician without a party. After belonging to the M-19 Democratic Alliance, the political successor to the guerrilla movement he joined in his youth, he was a congressman, mayor of Bogotá and presidential candidate under a succession of parties and movements, including Vía Alterna, Polo Democrático Alternativo, Progresistas and Colombia Humana.

He ultimately reached the presidency backed by the Historic Pact, then a broad and ideologically diverse coalition of progressive forces. Under Petro’s influence, the coalition was transformed into a unified political party. Today it holds 26 of Colombia’s 103 Senate seats, more than any other single bloc.

Far from stepping away from politics after handing over power on August 7, Petro went on to take the helm of the Historic Pact, after promoting claims of electoral fraud that found no support among the country’s electoral authorities. He still retains considerable popular appeal, and there has been persistent speculation that he could run in next year’s local elections for mayors and governors, though the former president himself has neither confirmed nor denied the possibility.

That has not shielded him from criticism within his own camp as the scandal continues to unfold. Senator Iván Cepeda, the Historic Pact’s presidential candidate, who narrowly lost the runoff election to De la Espriella, urged the left on Sunday not to cover up violence against women out of political loyalty, though he stopped short of mentioning Petro by name. He hardly needed to. Speaking in Valledupar, Cepeda acknowledged that the Historic Pact still harbors “deep-rooted machismo and patriarchy in its leadership and throughout its structures.”

That tendency, added Cepeda, who is expected to lead the opposition, “manifests itself in strongman politics and the cult of male leadership; in the concentration of decision-making within circles of men; in the discrediting of women who exercise authority,” as well as “in the silencing of complaints and the revictimization of those who dare to speak out about abuse.” Progressives, he argued, cannot assume they are “immune” to such practices simply because of their history of social struggles. He called for a “collective reckoning” in which men acknowledge their privileges and examine their own behavior.

Sociologist and political analyst Sara Tufano, one of the first voices to denounce sexist practices within Colombia’s left and the Historic Pact, believes there is clearly a far-right campaign to discredit Petro that goes beyond the allegations, which she says must nevertheless be thoroughly investigated.

“One can recognize the achievements of the Petro government and, at the same time, acknowledge that he is sexist,” she says. “One can denounce his practices and, at the same time, denounce Abelardo’s tax reform. One can recognize the abuse of power and, at the same time, know that the right will instrumentalize the allegations.”“

She continues: “When there are accusations of this nature, and even more so when they involve a former president and party leader, the most sensible thing would be for him to step aside.”

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2017 Spanish Property & News